THE 15 BEST Restaurants in Sea Isle City, NJ - With Menus, Reviews, Photos - Updated October 2024 (2024)

1

La Finestra Ristorante

Italian • $$$

Customers` Favorites

Tiramisu

Fried Calamari

Caprese Salad

Capellini Alla Sardinia

Gnocchi Gorgonzola

Caesar Salad

Chicken La Finestra

Lollipop Lamb Chops

Risotto Alla Scampi

Polenta Alla Gorgonzola

“Simply amazing! Perfect food, service and view. The best restaurant at the Jersey shore.”

4.4 Superb261 Reviews

Menu

2

Panzinis Pizza House - Sea Isle City

Pizza • $

Customers` Favorites

Garlic Knots

White Pizza

Greek Salad

Chicken Cheesesteak

Wings

Buffalo Chicken Pizza

Caesar Salad

Pepperoni Rolls

Cannoli

Tossed Salad

“I always make it a point to stop by when I'm in Sea Isle. The slices are excellent made with top notch ingredients, and they don't skimp on toppings either. I usually go for their buffalo chicken, and riccotta slices, and I haven't found another place that even comes close. I've been coming here for years, and plan to for years to come.”

4.7 Superb134 Reviews

Menu

3

Giovanni's Delicatessen

Deli • $

Customers` Favorites

Meatball Parm Sandwich

Italian Sub 12 Inch

Club Sandwich

“Best Italian deli ever! Best Italian hoagie loaded with so much meat. Homemade tuna salad was so good. The hot Roast pork sandwich with broccoli rabe was so tender and delicious! Can’t wait to return!”

4.9 Superb58 Reviews

Menu

4

Playa Bowls

Health Food • $$

Customers` Favorites

Coco Craze

“So delicious. We go to the one in sea isle city nj .We also have a residence in Annapolis Md . In the Annapolis Towne Centre . Would love to see one there . There are some open spaces and there is no other walk up food type place . No other ice cream or yogurt places there . Would be great location for a playa bowls . There is a True Food going up so there’s a health food trend that could be started !!”

4.9 Superb42 Reviews

Menu

5

Zio Niccolo Pizza

Pizza • $

Customers` Favorites

They Make a Great Pizza

Pepperoni Pizza Slice

Cheese Pizza

“We have been coming here for many years with our kids and are so happy to have experienced this pizza for the first time this year! We ordered a plain and then came back a couple days later and ordered veggie, plain and bacon. It’s so so good, and the owner was very cool. We’ll definitely be back.”

4.7 Superb52 Reviews

Menu

6

Mike's Seafood

Seafood • $$

Customers` Favorites

Fried

Flounder

Lobster Roll

Fish and Chips

Crab Balls

Clam Chowder

Lobster Bisque

Corn on the Cob

Seafood Platter

Shrimp Cocktail

“Our family has been eating at Mike’s Seafood for years and it’s always been wonderful, but our most recent visit was exceptional! We arrived about 5:00 to avoid the line and it was perfect. (By 6:00 the line was long!) My flounder with crabmeat in white wine/ butter sauce was AMAZING, truly one of the best meals I’ve had out in a long time. On top of that, the service was beyond enjoyable- every person was extremely friendly and asked us repeatedly if we enjoyed our meals. I highly recommend Mike’s seafood!”

4.5 Superb101 Reviews

Menu

7

Deli • $

“……………………………………………………………….”

4.7 Superb17 Reviews

Menu

8

A Modo Mio Ristorante

Italian • $$

Customers` Favorites

Risotto

Meatballs

Gnocchi Alle Noci

Veal Parmigiano

Mozzarella Fritta

“The food as always was delicious - every course was terrific. The noise level can be bad when it's a full restaurant but I'm willing to put up with it for the food. Service is always appropriately attentive without hovering. The ambiance is lacking though. The lighting is almost nonexistent. Pendants over the tables would create a pleasing atmosphere & provide some style but most importantly you could see what you're eating. Higher an interior designer than your restaurant would be 5 stars.”

4.3 Superb141 Reviews

Menu

9

Azzurra Pizza

Pizza • $

Customers` Favorites

Italian Sub

Famous White Pizza

Chicken Cheesesteak Special Sandwich

Build Your Own Cheese Pizza

Grandma Pizza with Pepperoni

Cheesesteak Stromboli

Large Cheese Pizza

Margherita Pizza

Chicken Wings

French Fries

“To put things into perspective, we drove 45 minutes just for THEIR pizza. Great family and amazing food! Be sure to try Grandma's pizza when you're there. 10/10!”

4.4 Superb44 Reviews

Menu

10

Hank Sauce

American • $

Customers` Favorites

Hawaiian Pork Tacos

Chicken Tacos

Pulled Pork

Southwest Shrimp Tacos and Crab and Clam Chowder Soup

Old Fashioned Hand Patty

Cilantro Buffalo Chicken

The Island Tuna Burger

Variety Hank Sauces

Crab Cake Sandwich

Baked Chicken Wings

“One of our favorites places. Nothing fancy, but good, creative food. Known for their hot sauce, but I enjoy their food just as much. Favorites include the wings and the pulled pork or ahi tuna tacos.”

4.4 Superb43 Reviews

Menu

11

O'Donnell's Pour House

Irish Pub • $$

Customers` Favorites

Crab Bisque

Chicken Milanese

Bangers and Mash

Fried Brie

Pizza

Maple Glazed Salmon Filet Mashed Garlic Potatoes and Green Beans Also Soup or Salad

O'Donnell's Crab Cakes

Broiled Salmon Fillet

Crab Cake Appetizer

House Crab Cakes

“AMAZING FOOD ALWAYS!!! All of their dishes are delicious.”

4.3 Superb110 Reviews

Menu

12

Dockside on Park

Cafe • $

THE 15 BEST Restaurants in Sea Isle City, NJ - With Menus, Reviews, Photos - Updated October 2024 (13) Recommended

Customers` Favorites

It Takes Two

The Big Dog

Avocado

“Went to Dockside on Park this morning in Sea Isle. This place is without a doubt the best place to visit for a cup of coffee - cold brew and breakfast sandwiches. The setting is incredibly peaceful with live music - where else do you find that at 10AM on a Saturday morning - and the menu is fantastic - we are never disappointed

Thank you to the staff for delivering once again!!”

4.6 Superb19 Reviews

Menu

13

Shorebreak Cafe

Cafe • $

Customers` Favorites

Cinnamon Bun

Croissants

Bruschetta Sandwich

Bacon Egg and Cheddar Croissant

Egg and Cheese Sandwich

Chocolate Chip Muffin

Crumb Cake Bites

Almond Croissant

Cheese Danish

Drip Coffee

“Shorebreak NEVER disappoints! Every pastry is better than the next! The bakers are so creative! Coffee is delicious! Sandwiches are so good! The Staff is friendly! If you go on the weekend - don't miss out on the cruffins!”

4.3 Superb70 Reviews

Menu

14

Topsail Steamer

Seafood • $$

Customers` Favorites

The Build Your Own Bay Bucket Base High Tider

Build Your Own Bay Bucket Base Low Tider

“Excellent quality seafood and amazing customer service. Alex is the best! If she isn't already in charge of something, she should be put in charge of something and definitely given a raise. The girl knows what she is doing ! Thanks for getting our order ready!!”

4.9 Superb8 Reviews

Menu

15

Sole

Italian • $$

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Boscaiola

Burrata Salad

Crab Gnocchi Arrabiata

Chicken Parmigiana

T I Pizza

“Outstanding service and top quality food!!! Amazing and delicious. Definitely our new go to place. Frank and his team are awesome!”

4.3 Superb46 Reviews

Menu

More Restaurants in Sea Isle City

Maryanne Pastry Shoppe

Bakery • $

“Bought long loaf of French bread, snowflake rolls, and the best banana bread ever. However the shining star was the lemon-currant scones. The best scone I have ever had. Found then on fb and called to order more. Vacationed in Sea Isle NJ summer 2022”

4.8 Superb14 Reviews

Menu

Ice Cream Shop • $

“We were so happy they were open late in the off season! Steve took care of a huge line with expediency and a smile. Lots of options for everyone so we all left happy! We'll be back!”

5 Superb10 Reviews

Menu

Dairy Queen (Treat)

Ice Cream Shop • $

Customers` Favorites

Wonder Woman Cookie Collision Blizzard Treat

Caramel Moolatté

Dilly Bar

DQ Sandwich

Banana Split

Mocha Moolatté

DQ 10 Round Cake

10 Blizzard Cake

S'Mores Blizzard Treat

Reese's Peanut Butter Cup Blizzard Treat

“Let me first start with a compliment to Joe here ! I called in a day before to make sure that I could get a cake for my niece , and he confirmed the opening time was 11 am , I was early the next day for 10 minutes and surprisingly he opened the door at 1050 am and welcomed me in to sort me out ! He was way cool and patient about the questions I had and explained well , I got a few ice creams for my staff back in the office and he made all of them with a smile . When the cake was ready he was all smiles and ring me up , and of coz because of his exceptional service I got more ice cream ! DQ ! you have a winner here that represent your establishment well !”

5 Superb7 Reviews

Menu

Nana and Poppy's Ice cream Parlor

Ice Cream Shop • $

Customers` Favorites

Death by Peanut Butter

“Best ice cream store in town! Family owned and operated. They make their own waffle cones- so good. Love the vibe there❤️”

4.6 Superb14 Reviews

Menu

Dudley's Dogs

Food Trucks • $

“Dudley has the best dogs at the shore and could not be a nicer guy....he has been providing beach people with a nice greeting and super dogs for many, many years....”

5 Superb6 Reviews

Menu

Rick's Breakfast House

Breakfast • $

Customers` Favorites

Home Fries

French Toast

Eggs Benedict

Scrapple

Sausage

Belgian Waffles w Blueberries & Whip Cream

Pancakes and Eggs with Waffle Fries

Western Omelette Split for 2

Hot Cake Big One

Hot Cakes

“Delightful restaurant in the corner of the parking lot. Staff are jovial and energetic, very helpful. This place knows how to handle the volume of customers! Great menu and excellent food. Delicious! Great themed art and shore memorabilia without being overdone or old. Very fresh and fun atmosphere!”

4.3 Superb42 Reviews

Menu

LouDogs

Hot Dogs • $

Customers` Favorites

Loudog

British Bulldog

Promenade

38th and Pleasure

Plain Hotdog

Shoobie

Lassie

“Lou Dogs are the best!!”

4.4 Superb22 Reviews

Menu

Mallon's Homemade Sticky Buns

Bakery • $$

“The best sticky bun.....drop the mic.”

5 Superb5 Reviews

Menu

Flip flop ice cream

Ice Cream Shop

“Amazing staff and a wonderful owner!! It is now our go to ice cream spot in Sea Isle City. Our family loves it so much I have to bring a tray in order to accommodate all the orders! Highly recommended from these Sea Isle residents!”

4.7 Superb7 Reviews

Menu

Anna's 63rd Street Cafe

Cafe • $

Customers` Favorites

Farro Salad

Super Salad

Bagel with Cream Cheese

Kids Breakfast Sandwich

Caprese Panini w Chicken

Fresh Fruit & Yogurt

Cinnamon Sugar Crepe

Cold Brew 20oz

Santa Fe Wrap

French Toast

“The food was amazing and the owners are hilarious. Great service”

4.3 Superb20 Reviews

Menu

Marita's Homemade Ice Cream

Ice Cream Shop • $

“Cash only. I really like their variety of ice cream flavors offered, especially the brookie dough. The line does get long and it does not move quickly. Service is slow, as they have limited employees working and limited space for those employees. Even with the wait, I still visit a couple of times each year. There is sufficient street parking - we usually drive there and have never had a problem finding parking within a two minute or less walk.

Parking: Plenty of parking available within a 2 minutes or less walk.

Kid-friendliness: Very kid-friendly

Wheelchair accessibility: The waiting line is wide enough for a wheelchair”

4.2 Good23 Reviews

Menu

auntie anne's

Pretzel Store • $

“Recommend everything. Great owner!”

5 Superb2 Reviews

Menu

Breakfast • $

Customers` Favorites

French Toast

Waffle

Scrambled or Fried

Hot Cakes

“It was perfect. Food was amazing! Staff was so nice. Loved the vibe!

They don't over pack it either, they just seat what they can serve. Big fan!!!”

4.2 Good16 Reviews

Menu

Seafood • $$$

Customers` Favorites

Seafood

Scallops

Oyster on the Half Shell

Lobster Roll Sandwich

Steamed Clam Bake

Captain's Platter

She Crab Soup

French Fries

Calamari

“We found Marie's by chance. We went to Mike's for dinner & they said they were closed. It was 8:30 pm. The website said they closed at 9:30 pm. So then we went to Marie's. It was awesome. The food was delicious & the service was beyond excellent. We didn't want to hold them up, if they were closing soon. The women at the front was so welcoming & told us to enjoy our meal, they didn't rush us at all. It was the 1st & only good meal we had the entire week. We will go to Marie's every time were in Sea Isle now.”

4.1 Good51 Reviews

Menu

Scoops

Ice Cream Shop • $

“best staff & ice cream! what’s not to love??”

4.1 Good23 Reviews

Menu

Oceancrat Sea Isle

Seafood • $$

Customers` Favorites

Seafood

Crab Legs

“Just picked up a bucket for two to share with my boyfriend for dinner and it was delicious! The bucket was a perfect portion for two with quality seafood that was cooked perfectly. The Ocean Crat special sauce on the seafood was amazing! Definitely one of the best seafood places on the island. 10/10 recommend for seafood takeout!”

4.1 Good15 Reviews

Menu

Breakfast • $

Customers` Favorites

Cinnamon Bun

Fruit Bowl

Egg Cheese

Bagel

“Always happy we visited Red White & Brew!love the food, coffee and staff!”

4 Good11 Reviews

Menu

Bubba Dogs

Hot Dogs • $

“Excellent and personable staff”

3.9 Good7 Reviews

Menu

Quincy's Original Lobster Rolls

Seafood • $

Customers` Favorites

Lobster Roll Opted for 50 More Lobster Wonder What It Looks Like at 50 Less

Lobster Mac N Cheese

“Wow, fantastic. Perfect temperature of roll versus filling, on the classic roll. Perfect amount of light mayo, with what seems like a house combination of celery seed and some sparing big pretzel salt crystals…. Just perfect munching overlooking the boardwalk, dunes and ocean in Ocean City boardwalk. And the lobster bisque was excellent. With the jumbo sized option on the classic rolls, there was lobster falling out of the sandwich before we could even pick it up. Just excellent.”

4 Good26 Reviews

Menu

Basilicos Marketplace

Italian • $$

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Saltimbocca

Slice of Pizza

House Salad

Pescatore

“Once again Basilicos hit it out of the park tonight! We ordered for delivery and it was at our door in 40 minutes.I had their eggplant parmigiana with spaghetti………as always it continues to be the best I have ever had. Huge portion with their deliciously fresh tomato gravy. He had one of the specials, crab marinara, which was made with an abundance of jumbo lump crab meat over spaghetti with their perfectly seasoned red sauce.And for the finale, we both had their homemade tiramisu! Definitely the best we’ve ever had and so fresh!”

4 Good32 Reviews

Menu

Andrea’s at Kix Bar

Italian • $$

“Andrea Trattoria catered our wedding in Sea Isle on 9/24/2022. The food was absolutely amazing! It was without a doubt the best buffet we've ever experienced. Tino worked with us to make sure we had a wide variety of apps, salads, and entrees. We requested Gulf shrimp and he was able to make that happen for us! Thank you, Tino and team at Andrea Trattoria!”

3.9 Good12 Reviews

Menu

Bright Spot Sea Isle

American • $

Customers` Favorites

Belgian Waffle

Chunky Monkey French Toast

Avocado Toast

Meat Lovers

9th Street Chicken Sandwich

“We had breakfast from Bright Spot and it was amazing! Everything was perfect and so fresh! Can’t wait to go back!!”

4 Good52 Reviews

Menu

Anthony's Sea Isle City

Italian • $$

Customers` Favorites

Baked Clams

Veal Saltimbocca

Fried Jersey Tomato w Jumbo Lump Crab in Lobster Cream

Veal Chop - Best in the City

Meatball Salad with Ricotta

Jumbo Lump Crab and Shrimp

Anthony's Meatball Grande

Shrimp with Crab Imperial

Peach Caprese Salad

Seafood Fra Diavolo

“Great place with delicious cuisine and friendly staff!”

4 Good65 Reviews

Menu

Henris @ Braca Cafe

Cafe • $$

Customers` Favorites

Double Chocolate Cake

Mushrooms Stuffed

Italian Calamari

Grilled Chicken

Chicken Alfredo

“Great atmosphere, good service, tasty food.”

3.9 Good27 Reviews

Menu

La Fontana Coast - Sea Isle City

Italian • $$

Customers` Favorites

Dessert

Bruschetta

Pasta Special

Fried Calamari

Penne Alla Vodka

Chicken Francaise

Rigatoni Alfredo

Lobster Ravioli

Seafood Risotto

Arugula Salad

“We ordered takeout; the food was amazing! The menu is diverse and the portions are large. We enjoyed the mushroom risotto, rigatoni bolognese, and the halibut special. The staff was helpful and friendly. Thank you so much!”

4 Good191 Reviews

Menu

Steve's Grilled Cheese and Quesadilla Company

Grills • $

Customers` Favorites

Fries

Quesadilla

Cheesesteak

Macaroni and Cheese Bites Grilled Cheese Sandwich

Chicken Parmigiana Sandwich

“Nice place..good friendly service. Great grilled cheese!!”

3.9 Good30 Reviews

Menu

Megu Sushi Sea Isle

Japanese • $$

“great bento box! had chicken teriyaki with California roll. fresh sushi. great service. reasonably priced. nice atmosphere.”

3.7 Good11 Reviews

Menu

The Point - Sea Isle City

Bar & Grill • $

Customers` Favorites

Frozen Sneaky Monkey with a Floater

Chicken Skewers

“Spent a very nice afternoon unwinding from a hectic morning in the shade of one of the bars at The Point. Cool breezes and ambiance. Nice music and at the right volume to allow for conversation.”

3.9 Good48 Reviews

Menu

Henri's Bar

Bar • $$

Customers` Favorites

Salads

Tiramisu

Cioppino

“Great atmosphere, good service, tasty food.”

3.9 Good50 Reviews

Menu

DeNunzio's Brick Oven Pizza and Grille

Pizza • $

Customers` Favorites

Vegan

Gelato

Salad

Sauce

Pie

Brick Oven Traditional Cheese Pizza

Grilled Chicken Bruschetta Wrap

Cheese Steak DeNunzio Sub

Fire Burger and Fries

BBQ Chicken Pizza

“Excellent service, staff and FOOD! Smash burgers are great! Pizza… great! Thank you!!!”

3.8 Good65 Reviews

Menu

Mrs. Brizzle's Buns Inc

Bakery • $

Customers` Favorites

Sandwiches

Cinnamon Bun

Cinnamon Roll

Sticky Buns

Italian Hoagie

Mushroom Cheesesteak

Breakfast Bagel

Chicken Cheesesteak Sub

Cheesesteak Hoagie

Any Deli Sandwich

“Started going to Mrs. Brizzles about 7 years ago. The owner Mike & his wife are 2 of the nicest people you could ever meet. Not only are their sandwiches huge, so are their personalities. Our entire family have made it a point to get to Mrs. Brizzles while vacationing at the Jersey Shore. You will not be disappointed! Would give them 6 stars!”

3.8 Good73 Reviews

Menu

Carmen's Seafood Restaurant

Seafood • $$

Customers` Favorites

Clam

Crab Cakes

French Fries

Spaghetti and Meatballs

Shrimp and Scallop

Stuffed Flounder

Baked Potato

Double Lobster Stuffed with Crab

House Dressing on Side Salad

Oysters on the Half Shell

“We love eating here with our friends. The food is always fantastic and very friendly service. Even the valet guys are great! Or just pull up on your boat. Highly recommend!”

3.7 Good97 Reviews

Menu

Pizza • $

Customers` Favorites

Sandwiches

Old Italian Pizza

Upside Down Pizza

Mozzarella Sticks

Cheesesteak

Pepperoni and Cheese Stromboli

Chicken Parm Sandwich

Hamburger

“The pizzas were vary good so soft and there was a lot of cheese which I loved. It was definitely cooked in a pizza oven from the taste of it. Delivery was speedy fast. 5 stars highly recommend.”

3.6 Good62 Reviews

Menu

THE 15 BEST Restaurants in Sea Isle City, NJ - With Menus, Reviews, Photos - Updated October 2024 (2024)
Top Articles
Latest Posts
Recommended Articles
Article information

Author: Foster Heidenreich CPA

Last Updated:

Views: 6176

Rating: 4.6 / 5 (76 voted)

Reviews: 83% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Foster Heidenreich CPA

Birthday: 1995-01-14

Address: 55021 Usha Garden, North Larisa, DE 19209

Phone: +6812240846623

Job: Corporate Healthcare Strategist

Hobby: Singing, Listening to music, Rafting, LARPing, Gardening, Quilting, Rappelling

Introduction: My name is Foster Heidenreich CPA, I am a delightful, quaint, glorious, quaint, faithful, enchanting, fine person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.